MENU TAMBAHAN
Publication Ethics
MEDIA: Jurnal Filsafat dan Teologi is a peer-reviewed scholarly journal dedicated to publishing original research in philosophy, theology, and related interdisciplinary fields. The journal is committed to maintaining high standards of academic integrity, editorial independence, transparency, and ethical scholarly publishing.
The journal's publication ethics policies are informed by the principles and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and recognised international standards of responsible scholarly publishing.
All parties involved in the publication process, including authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher, are expected to uphold these ethical principles and fulfil their respective responsibilities.
1. Responsibilities of Editors
1.1. Fairness and Editorial Independence
Editors evaluate submitted manuscripts solely on the basis of their scholarly merit, originality, methodological rigour, clarity, significance, and relevance to the journal's aims and scope.
Editorial decisions must be made without discrimination based on race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, nationality, religious beliefs, political views, institutional affiliation, or other characteristics unrelated to the scholarly quality of the manuscript.
The Editor-in-Chief retains responsibility for the journal's editorial content and publication decisions. Editorial decisions must remain independent of inappropriate commercial, institutional, governmental, or personal influences.
1.2. Confidentiality
Editors and editorial staff must protect the confidentiality of all submitted manuscripts and related communications.
Information concerning a manuscript may be disclosed only to the corresponding author, assigned editors, reviewers, prospective reviewers, authorised editorial advisers, the publisher, or other parties where disclosure is necessary for legitimate editorial or ethical procedures.
Unpublished manuscripts and confidential editorial communications must not be disclosed or used for purposes unrelated to the editorial process.
1.3. Conflicts of Interest
Editors must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that could compromise their impartiality.
Such conflicts may arise from personal relationships, professional collaborations, institutional affiliations, financial interests, or academic competition.
Editors must not use unpublished information, data, arguments, or ideas obtained through editorial responsibilities for their own research or personal advantage without the authors' explicit written consent.
Where a conflict of interest exists, the manuscript must be reassigned to an editor who can evaluate it independently.
1.4. Editorial Decisions
The journal employs a double-anonymous peer-review system, under which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from one another.
Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial screening are evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with appropriate disciplinary expertise.
The Editor-in-Chief or an authorised handling editor is responsible for determining whether a manuscript should be accepted, revised, subjected to further review, or rejected.
Editorial decisions are informed by reviewers' recommendations, the scholarly quality and significance of the manuscript, compliance with publication ethics, and applicable legal requirements, including copyright and defamation law.
Reviewers' recommendations inform but do not determine the final editorial decision.
1.5. Handling Allegations of Research Misconduct
Editors are responsible for responding appropriately to credible allegations or evidence of research misconduct involving submitted or published articles.
Potential misconduct includes plagiarism, data fabrication or falsification, duplicate publication, inappropriate authorship, undisclosed conflicts of interest, and manipulation of the peer-review process.
Allegations will be evaluated fairly and confidentially. Authors and other relevant parties should be given an appropriate opportunity to respond.
Where necessary, the Editorial Board may seek clarification, request supporting documentation, consult independent experts, or refer matters to relevant institutions.
Ethical concerns may be investigated even when identified after publication.
1.6. Corrections, Retractions, and Expressions of Concern
Where significant errors or ethical concerns are identified in published articles, the journal will consider appropriate post-publication measures.
Depending on the nature and seriousness of the issue, these may include:
-
Corrections: To address significant errors that do not invalidate the principal findings or arguments.
-
Retractions: Where findings or conclusions are unreliable or serious publication misconduct has occurred.
-
Expressions of Concern: Where substantial concerns exist but the available evidence is inconclusive or an investigation remains unresolved.
Post-publication notices must be clearly identified, appropriately linked to the original article, and accompanied by sufficient information to explain the editorial action.
2. Responsibilities of Reviewers
2.1. Contribution to Editorial Decisions
Peer review assists editors in making informed publication decisions and provides authors with constructive scholarly feedback.
Reviewers are expected to assess manuscripts fairly, critically, and independently, contributing to the quality and integrity of published research.
2.2. Professional Competence and Timeliness
Reviewers should accept invitations only when they possess the necessary expertise and can complete the assessment within the agreed timeframe.
Reviewers who lack sufficient expertise, anticipate delays, or are unable to conduct an impartial assessment must inform the editor promptly.
2.3. Confidentiality
Manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents.
Reviewers must not disclose, reproduce, distribute, or discuss manuscript content with unauthorised individuals.
Unpublished data, ideas, arguments, and interpretations obtained through peer review must not be used for personal or professional advantage.
These confidentiality obligations also apply to individuals who decline review invitations.
Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts or unpublished manuscript content to external generative AI services without explicit editorial authorisation and appropriate confidentiality safeguards.
2.4. Objectivity and Constructive Criticism
Reviews must be conducted objectively and supported by clear academic reasoning.
Reviewers should provide constructive, evidence-based comments that enable authors to improve the quality, coherence, methodological rigour, and scholarly contribution of their manuscripts.
Personal criticism, discriminatory remarks, hostile language, and unsupported judgements are unacceptable.
2.5. Acknowledgement of Sources
Reviewers should identify important published works relevant to the manuscript that have not been appropriately acknowledged.
Reviewers should also notify the editor of substantial similarities or overlaps between the manuscript under review and other published or unpublished works of which they are aware.
Recommendations to cite additional literature must be academically justified and must not be used to manipulate citations for personal or institutional benefit.
2.6. Conflicts of Interest
Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest arising from financial, personal, professional, institutional, intellectual, or other relationships.
Where such conflicts could compromise the independence of the review, reviewers must decline the invitation or seek guidance from the handling editor.
Reviewers must not exploit information obtained through peer review for personal, academic, or commercial gain.
3. Responsibilities of Authors
3.1. Originality and Plagiarism
Authors must submit original scholarly work that has not been previously published and is not simultaneously under consideration elsewhere.
All sources, quotations, arguments, and interpretations derived from existing scholarship must be appropriately acknowledged.
The journal conducts similarity screening using iThenticate as part of its initial editorial assessment.
A maximum overall similarity index of 25% is applied as an initial screening criterion. However, similarity percentages do not constitute definitive evidence of the presence or absence of plagiarism.
The Editorial Board assesses similarity reports in context and may request revisions or investigate substantial unattributed overlap regardless of the overall similarity score.
3.2. Accuracy and Research Integrity
Authors must present research findings, evidence, interpretations, and arguments accurately and responsibly.
Fabrication, falsification, selective misrepresentation of evidence, and deliberate distortion of sources are prohibited.
Authors must provide sufficient methodological information to enable readers to assess the credibility and validity of their research.
3.3. Authorship and Contributions
Authorship must accurately reflect substantive scholarly contributions to the research and manuscript.
All listed authors must approve the final manuscript and agree to its submission.
Individuals who have contributed to the research but do not qualify for authorship should be acknowledged appropriately.
Guest authorship, honorary authorship, and the omission of legitimate contributors are unacceptable.
3.4. Multiple and Duplicate Submissions
Authors must not submit the same manuscript simultaneously to multiple journals.
Substantial republication of previously published research without appropriate acknowledgement and editorial justification is prohibited.
Authors must disclose relevant relationships between the submitted manuscript and their previously published or concurrently submitted work.
3.5. Research Ethics and Informed Consent
Research involving human participants must comply with applicable ethical principles and relevant institutional and legal requirements.
Where applicable, authors must obtain informed consent, protect participants' confidentiality, and provide information regarding ethical approval or documented exemptions.
Research involving sensitive personal information must demonstrate appropriate safeguards for privacy and data protection.
3.6. Conflicts of Interest and Funding
Authors must disclose financial and non-financial interests that could reasonably be perceived as influencing the research.
All relevant funding sources, grants, and institutional support must be acknowledged.
Where no conflicts of interest exist, authors should provide an appropriate declaration.
3.7. Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence
Authors remain fully responsible for the originality, accuracy, integrity, and scholarly quality of their manuscripts, including content prepared with the assistance of generative artificial intelligence.
Generative AI tools must not be listed as authors.
Authors must disclose substantive use of generative AI in research preparation, analysis, translation, or manuscript drafting, including the purpose and extent of its use.
Authors are responsible for independently verifying AI-assisted content, references, quotations, and interpretations.
The use of generative AI does not diminish authors' accountability for the submitted manuscript.
3.8. Citation and Referencing
Authors must accurately acknowledge all scholarly sources in accordance with The Chicago Manual of Style, 18th Edition (Notes and Bibliography).
Citations, footnotes, and bibliographical entries must be complete, consistent, and verifiable.
Where available, Digital Object Identifiers (DOIs) should be provided as active hyperlinks.
3.9. Correction of Published Errors
Authors who identify significant errors or inaccuracies in their published work must promptly notify the Editorial Board.
Authors are expected to cooperate with editors in investigating the issue and implementing appropriate corrective measures.
4. Responsibilities of the Publisher
The publisher is responsible for supporting the journal's editorial independence, publication integrity, and adherence to ethical publishing standards.
The publisher must not exert inappropriate influence over manuscript evaluation, peer-review outcomes, or publication decisions.
The publisher is expected to cooperate with the Editorial Board in addressing allegations of misconduct, managing post-publication corrections, and maintaining the accessibility and integrity of the scholarly record.
5. Complaints and Appeals
Authors, reviewers, and readers may submit complaints concerning editorial procedures, peer-review conduct, suspected ethical violations, or publication decisions.
Complaints must be supported by relevant information and will be assessed confidentially and fairly.
Authors may appeal editorial decisions where they believe that significant procedural irregularities, factual misunderstandings, or substantial evaluative errors have occurred.
Appeals will be assessed by the Editor-in-Chief or an appropriately authorised editor who has no relevant conflict of interest.
An appeal does not guarantee reconsideration or reversal of an editorial decision.
6. Copyright and Licensing
Authors retain copyright ownership of their published works and grant MEDIA: Jurnal Filsafat dan Teologi the right of first publication.
Articles are published under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).
This licence permits copying, redistribution, adaptation, and commercial reuse, provided that appropriate attribution is given to the original authors and publication source and the applicable licence conditions are respected.
7. Commitment to Ethical Publishing
MEDIA: Jurnal Filsafat dan Teologi is committed to maintaining a responsible, independent, and transparent scholarly publishing environment.
The journal seeks to uphold academic freedom, intellectual integrity, fair editorial assessment, responsible authorship, and the reliability of the published scholarly record.
The Editorial Board encourages authors, reviewers, editors, and readers to report credible concerns regarding research integrity or publication ethics.
Editorial Contact: jurnalmediastfsp@gmail.com
The Editorial Board
MEDIA: Jurnal Filsafat dan Teologi





